Log in or sign up

Loading your account…

Two people at a table looking at a model of an apartment tower, with blank papers in front of them

For investors

Questions to Ask a Real Estate Syndication Sponsor

Questions to put to a syndication sponsor before you invest: a track record you can check, fees, conflicts, reporting and what happens in a bad deal.

Category

For investors

Written by

The JekkyStay team

Published

· 11 min read

Quick answer

Before you invest with a real estate syndication sponsor, ask questions that test five things: a track record you can check yourself, how the sponsor is paid in good and bad outcomes, its conflicts of interest, how and when it reports, and what it did the last time a deal went wrong. Get every answer in writing.

If you are new to syndications, start with our guide to how real estate syndication works, and our explainer on 506(b) vs 506(c) offerings.

This is general information, not tax, legal or investment advice.

Key takeaways

  • Ask for every deal the sponsor has done, including the ones that lost money, and check what you can yourself: Form D filings on the SEC's site, BrokerCheck for anyone selling the deal, and court records.
  • Ask how the sponsor gets paid when the deal does badly, not only when it does well, and how much of its own money is at risk next to yours.
  • Ask about every affiliated company that earns a fee from the deal, and how conflicts between the sponsor's deals are handled.
  • Ask for a sample investor report from a past deal and the dates you will receive reports, financials and tax forms.
  • Ask what the sponsor did the last time a deal went wrong: capital calls, paused distributions, loan workouts, and what limited partners could vote on.
In this guide
  1. Why the sponsor matters more than the property
  2. A track record you can verify
  3. Fees and how the sponsor gets paid
  4. Conflicts of interest
  5. Reporting: what you will see, and when
  6. When a deal goes badly
  7. Extra questions for vacation rental syndications
  8. How to ask, and what to do with the answers
  9. The bottom line

Why the sponsor matters more than the property

The short answer is that in a syndication you hand control to one team for years, so the team's judgment and honesty drive the outcome as much as the building does.

As a limited partner you don't pick the manager, approve the budget or decide when to sell. The sponsor does. A good property with a careless sponsor can lose money; an average property with a careful one can come through a hard market intact. The pitch deck tells you about the property. The questions below tell you about the people.

There is a real downside to keep in mind before you start. Even with perfect diligence, you are still taking on property risk, loan risk and years of illiquidity, and you can lose all of what you put in. Good questions reduce the chance of a bad sponsor. They don't remove the risk of a bad market.

A large modern apartment complex with balconies on a sunny day
The building in the deck is only half the decision; the team running it for the next several years is the other half.

A track record you can verify

The answer is to ask for every deal, not a highlight reel, and then check the parts you can confirm without the sponsor's help.

A sponsor's marketing usually shows its best results. What you want is the full list. Ask:

  1. Can you send a list of every deal you have sponsored, with the purchase date, the amount raised, and whether it is still held, sold or lost? A sponsor that has done twelve deals and shows you five has chosen what you see.
  2. For each sold deal, what did you project at the start and what happened? The gap between projection and outcome tells you how the sponsor underwrites. Consistent misses in one direction are a pattern.
  3. Which deals underperformed, and why? Every sponsor with a long record has some. A sponsor who says none did is either very new or not being straight with you.
  4. Was this specific team running those deals? A firm's record may come from people who have since left.
  5. Can I talk to investors from a deal that went badly? References the sponsor picks will be happy ones. Ask for a name from a hard deal.

Then check on your own:

  • Form D filings. Companies raising money under Regulation D file a short notice called Form D. The SEC's Form D FAQ says a company "must file the Form D notice within 15 calendar days after the first sale of securities in the offering," and that "all Form D filings, including their accession numbers, are publicly available on the SEC website." Search the SEC's filings for the sponsor's entities. You can see which offerings were reported, roughly when, and how much they set out to raise. Compare that with the deal list you were given. A filed Form D does not mean the SEC reviewed or approved the offering.
  • BrokerCheck for whoever is selling it. If a broker or adviser brought you the deal, look them up. FINRA says to "use FINRA's BrokerCheck tool to research professionals who sell securities, provide advice or both," and BrokerCheck's FAQ says reports are free and that neither individuals nor firms are told about your search. It also pulls basic adviser data from the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure database. Know its limits: the FAQ says "BrokerCheck does not disclose information that investment professionals have not reported or are not required to report." Many sponsors are not registered brokers at all, so a missing record is not a clean bill of health.
  • Court and public records. FINRA's guidance on working with any investment professional suggests an internet search of the person and their firm, including "checking to see if an individual has a criminal record." For a sponsor, add a search of court records in the states where it operates for lawsuits by investors, lenders or contractors.

Fees and how the sponsor gets paid

The answer is to ask how the sponsor earns money when the deal goes badly, because that shows whose interests come first.

Our syndication explainer lists the usual fees. Rather than repeat that list, ask about alignment:

  1. How much of your own money is in this deal, and is it in the same class as mine? Sponsor money that sits behind or alongside investors means the sponsor feels losses too. Money in a preferred position, or fees rolled in as "investment," is a different thing.
  2. Which of your fees are paid regardless of performance? Acquisition, asset management and refinance fees can be earned even if investors never see a profit.
  3. If investors lose money, what does the sponsor still collect over the life of the deal? Ask for that in dollars.
  4. Does any fee grow if the deal gets bigger or more leveraged? A fee on total purchase price or total loan amount rewards paying more or borrowing more.
  5. Does the asset management fee stop or defer if distributions stop? Some agreements defer it; many don't.
  6. Do you earn anything from the lender, broker or insurer on this deal? Referral fees and rebates belong in the disclosure.

To test how a deal holds up once fees come out, run the numbers through our free investor tools, such as the deal analyzer and the DSCR calculator.

Conflicts of interest

The answer is to map every company that earns money from the deal and ask which ones the sponsor owns or is related to.

Conflicts are common and not always bad. An in-house property manager can be good at the job. The problem is when nobody outside the sponsor checks whether the price and performance are fair. Ask:

QuestionA good answer sounds likeA warning sign
Which companies earning fees are affiliated with you?A written list with each fee and how it is set"We handle everything in-house" with no list
How are affiliate fees compared with market rates?Bids or third-party quotes on file, and a cap in the agreementNo comparison, no cap
Can limited partners replace an affiliated manager that underperforms?Yes, with the vote and process written in the agreementOnly the sponsor can decide
Do any of your deals lend to or buy from each other?No, or only with disclosure and an independent checkMoney moves between deals with no disclosure
Are you raising a new deal that competes for your time or the same buyers and renters?A clear answer on staffing and how you split attentionVague answers, or a new raise while this one struggles
Can you sell this property to another of your funds?Only with an independent valuation and investor consentAllowed at the sponsor's discretion

A sponsor with several active deals in one market faces a quiet conflict: the same tenants, guests or buyers can go to either property. Ask how the sponsor decides which property gets the next lease, the best rate or the first offer.

Reporting: what you will see, and when

The answer is to ask for a sample report from a past deal and the dates you will receive each document, before you commit.

Promises about "transparency" are easy. A real report from an existing deal shows what you will actually get. Ask:

  1. Can I see an investor report from one of your current deals, including one that is behind plan? How a sponsor reports a miss tells you a lot.
  2. How often will I get a report, and what is in it? Look for income and expenses against budget, occupancy, the loan balance and its terms, cash reserves and capital spending.
  3. Are the financial statements audited or reviewed by an outside accountant, or prepared in-house?
  4. When do Schedule K-1s go out each year? Late K-1s can delay your own tax return.
  5. Where do distributions come from? Ask the sponsor to show whether each distribution came from property income, reserves, a loan or new investor money.

That last question matters. In a 2013 notice on how firms describe real estate programs, FINRA wrote that "some real estate programs fund a portion of their distributions through return of principal or loan proceeds," and that "because borrowed funds were used to pay distributions, the distribution rate may not be sustainable." The notice was aimed at brokers selling non-traded programs, but the point carries to any syndication: a steady check is not proof the property is earning it.

When a deal goes badly

The answer is to ask what the sponsor did on its worst deal, and to read what the agreement lets the sponsor do without you.

Most pitches describe the plan. Few describe the exit when the plan fails. The questions here are uncomfortable on purpose:

  1. Tell me about your worst deal. What went wrong, when did you tell investors, and what did you do? Listen for when investors heard the news compared with when the sponsor knew.
  2. Can you make a capital call, and what happens if I don't contribute? Many agreements let the sponsor ask for more money. Investors who don't send it can be diluted, sometimes heavily.
  3. Can you pause distributions, and on what trigger?
  4. What are the loan's maturity date, rate type and extension terms, and who signed any guarantee? A loan coming due in a weak market forces a refinance or a sale on the lender's timeline.
  5. What can limited partners vote on? A sale, a refinance, new debt, an amendment to the agreement, removing the sponsor. Find out how many votes each takes.
  6. Can the sponsor be removed, and for what? Some agreements allow removal only for fraud or gross negligence proven in court, which is a very high bar.
  7. What happens if a key person leaves or dies? Ask whether the agreement names key people and what follows if they go.
  8. If the property is sold at a loss, in what order is money paid out? The lender comes first; ask where your class sits after that, and whether any sponsor fees come ahead of returning investor capital.

FINRA's general advice applies here too: steer clear of anyone who "pushes you to invest quickly" or "refuses to provide information for you to consider carefully." A sponsor who won't send the operating agreement until after you wire money has answered several of these questions already.

Extra questions for vacation rental syndications

The answer is to add questions on regulation, platform dependence and who runs the guest side, because short-term rentals add risks an apartment building doesn't carry.

How to ask, and what to do with the answers

The answer is to send the questions in writing, keep the replies, and have your own attorney and CPA read the documents.

Email the questions before a call so the answers come back in a form you can keep. Compare them with the private placement memorandum, the operating agreement and the subscription agreement. Where the documents and the pitch disagree, the documents govern.

You will rarely get a perfect answer to every question. Weigh them together: a sponsor that is open about a past loss, puts real money in, discloses its affiliates and sends sample reports without being asked is in a very different place from one that is vague on all four. Walking away from a deal costs nothing. If you are considering investing alongside JekkyStay, the same questions apply to us; see the investors page.

This is general information, not tax, legal or investment advice. Speak with a licensed professional about your own situation.

The bottom line

Ask for every deal, not the best ones, and check what you can on your own through Form D filings, BrokerCheck and court records. Ask how the sponsor is paid when things go badly, which affiliates earn fees, what reports you will get and when, and what the sponsor did on its worst deal. Get the answers in writing, read the documents with your own advisers, and walk away from anyone who rushes you.

Frequently asked questions

How do I check a syndication sponsor's track record?

Ask for a list of every past deal with dates, what was projected and what happened. Then check what you can: search the SEC's filings for the sponsor's Form D notices, look up anyone selling the deal on FINRA BrokerCheck, search court records for the sponsor and its principals, and speak to investors from deals the sponsor did not pick for you.

What does a Form D tell me about a syndication?

A Form D is a short public notice a company files with the SEC after the first sale in an exempt offering. The SEC says it must be filed within 15 calendar days after the first sale and that all Form D filings are publicly available on its website. It confirms an offering was reported, not that the SEC reviewed or approved it.

What is a conflict of interest in a syndication?

Any place where the sponsor or its affiliates earn money in a way that may not line up with investors' interests: an affiliated property manager or contractor, fees on refinancing or sale, loans between the sponsor's own deals, or a sponsor raising money for a new deal while an old one struggles.

What happens if a syndication deal goes badly?

It depends on the operating agreement. Distributions can be paused, the sponsor may ask investors for more money in a capital call, investors who don't contribute can be diluted, the loan may be modified or refinanced, or the property may be sold at a loss. Read the agreement for each of these before you invest.

Should I worry if distributions come from loans or new money?

Ask where distributions come from. FINRA has warned that some real estate programs fund distributions through return of principal or loan proceeds, and that when borrowed funds are used to pay distributions, the distribution rate may not be sustainable.

Is this investment advice?

No. This guide is general information, not tax, legal or investment advice. Review any offering documents with your own attorney, CPA and financial adviser before you invest.

Sources

  1. SEC: Frequently asked questions and answers on Form D
  2. FINRA: Working with an investment professional
  3. FINRA: BrokerCheck FAQ
  4. FINRA Regulatory Notice 13-18: communications on real estate programs

Invest in large group homes

Accredited investors can register for future JekkyStay opportunities.